Figures relate to tax year 2026 (US) · 2026-27 (UK)
The flat has seventy-odd years left and the mortgage lender has started asking questions. You pay a premium, sign the new lease, and move on.
A lease extension produces no tax bill in either country at the time, and that is the trap.
The cost matters years later, when you come to sell.
Key takeaways
- The premium is capital spending, not a deductible expense.
- It adds to your cost base in both countries.
- Nothing is taxable on you at the time you extend.
- The freeholder has a gain, and that is their problem.
- Legal and valuation fees add to the base too.
- Marriage value has no American equivalent concept.
- Currency movement can create a gain on the eventual sale.
- Keep the completion paperwork for decades, not years.
What is a lease extension?
Buying more years on a leasehold flat from the freeholder, usually for a premium. According to GOV.UK guidance on capital gains, costs of acquiring or enhancing an asset are capital rather than running expenses. So the premium is an investment in the flat.
Our guide to selling a UK home covers disposals.
A lease extension buys years, it does not pay rent.
Can you deduct the premium?
Not against rental income, because it is capital rather than a running cost. Landlords ask this constantly and the answer disappoints every time. It goes against the eventual gain instead.
Our guide to UK rental income covers lettings.
A lease extension reduces the gain, not the rent.
Where the premium goes
| Item | UK | US |
|---|---|---|
| Premium paid | Enhancement expenditure | Added to basis |
| Legal fees | Allowable | Added to basis |
| Valuation fees | Allowable | Added to basis |
| Deduct against rent | No | No |
| Taxable on you at the time | No | No |
| Relevant on sale | Yes | Yes |
Does America treat it the same way?
Broadly yes, because improving or extending an interest in property adds to its basis. A higher basis means a smaller gain when you sell. So both systems park the money until disposal.
Our guide to exchange rates on a US return covers conversion.
Both systems hold the lease extension cost until sale.
A worked example
Take an illustrative case. An American in London extends the lease on a flat bought years ago, paying a premium of £42,000 plus £6,000 of fees.
Nothing appears on either return for that year, because no disposal has happened.
When the flat sells later, the £48,000 comes off the gain in Britain and adds to basis in America.
Without the completion statement, that £48,000 is simply lost and the gain is overstated on both returns.
Why is the paperwork so often lost?
Because nothing happens at the time, so nobody files it anywhere useful. In our practice the completion statement turns up missing a decade later, when it matters most. Conveyancers do not keep files forever.
Our guide to a tax transcript from abroad covers records.
Scan the lease extension papers the week you complete.
What is marriage value?
The uplift in the flat's value created by extending, which British law can require you to share with the freeholder. It exists in the valuation rather than in the tax code. So it affects the price you pay and nothing else.
Our guide to UK capital losses covers the gains rules.
Marriage value changes the price of a lease extension only.
Is there an American equivalent?
No, because long residential leaseholds are unusual there and the concept never arose. The American return simply sees a sum paid to acquire an interest. So explaining marriage value to an American adviser rarely helps.
Our guide to US property for UK residents covers the other direction.
America sees a payment and a higher basis.
Does the freeholder's gain affect you?
Not at all, because their disposal is their own tax event and you are simply the buyer in that transaction. Nothing on their side reaches your return in either country, however large the figure happens to be for them.
Our guide to inheriting UK property covers other interests.
Their gain is entirely their problem.
What if you buy the freehold instead?
Collective enfranchisement with other flat owners works similarly, with your share being capital spending. The structure is more complex because a company usually holds it. So an American owner should check that company's reporting.
Our guide to a UK company with an American owner covers the forms.
A freehold company brings its own reporting.
Why does that company matter?
Because an American with an interest in a foreign company can face long annual forms. A residents' management company is still a foreign company. So check the shareholding before assuming it is harmless.
Our guide to Form 5471 categories covers the filings.
Even a flat management company counts.
What about stamp duty on the extension?
A premium above the threshold can attract stamp duty, which is itself a cost of acquisition. That adds to the base alongside the premium. So include the duty in the figure you record.
Our guide to the SDLT surcharge covers stamp duty.
Stamp duty joins the cost base too.
Does a mortgage change the treatment?
Borrowing to fund the premium does not change its character as capital spending. Interest on a loan for a let property may be relievable here under the current rules. So the loan and the premium are separate questions.
Our guide to a UK mortgage and currency gains covers borrowing.
The borrowing is a separate question.
What about the currency movement?
America measures basis in dollars at the rate on the day you paid. A premium paid when the pound was strong gives a larger dollar basis. So the exchange rate on completion day matters permanently.
Our guide to currency gains on bank accounts covers currency.
Record the rate on completion day.
Can that create a gain by itself?
It can, because the American gain is measured entirely in dollars. A flat that barely moved in sterling can show a dollar gain or loss. So currency alone can change the answer on one return.
Our guide to UK gilts and US tax covers currency effects.
Sterling flat can still mean a dollar gain.
What if you sell without extending?
A short lease usually sells at a discount, which simply produces a lower price and a smaller gain. Some buyers negotiate for the seller to start the process first. So the decision is commercial rather than driven by tax.
Our guide to the 60-day CGT report covers reporting a sale.
Tax rarely decides whether to do a lease extension.
Does a lease extension affect main residence relief?
The British relief for your own home can still cover the gain including the enhancement. America has its own exclusion with quite different conditions. So the reliefs do not line up even when both apply.
Our guide to selling a UK home as an American covers the reliefs.
The two home reliefs rarely match up.
How different are the two reliefs?
Britain can exempt the whole gain on your only home with no cash cap. America caps its exclusion at a fixed dollar figure. So a large gain on a London flat often falls outside the American relief entirely.
Our guide to the net investment income tax covers the extra charge.
The American exclusion is capped and the British is not.
What if the flat is let?
Then no main residence relief applies and the full gain is taxable in both countries. The extension premium becomes more valuable, since it is all that reduces the gain. So landlords should guard the paperwork especially carefully.
Our guide to the non-resident landlord scheme covers lettings.
Landlords need that receipt most of all.
Does an inherited flat differ?
The starting base is the value at death rather than what anybody paid. An extension after inheriting then adds to that figure. So the two numbers come from different events and both need recording.
Our guide to UK inheritance tax covers estates.
Inherited property starts from the death value.
What records should you keep?
The completion statement, the new lease, the solicitor's bill, the valuation report and the exchange rate on the day. Those five turn a lost deduction into a certain one decades later.
Our guide to US tax deadlines for expats covers the dates.
Five lease extension documents, kept until you sell.
Where should you keep them?
Somewhere that survives house moves, solicitors closing and email accounts lapsing. A scanned folder with the deeds is the usual answer. So treat it as part of the title rather than as a tax paper.
Our guide to the IRS online account covers digital records.
Keep it with the deeds, not the tax file.
When should you get advice?
Before completing if a company or an unusual structure is involved, and certainly before selling. A straightforward statutory extension needs recording rather than advising. The sale is where the money is decided.
Our guide to choosing a US-UK tax accountant covers getting help.
The sale year is when it counts.
Why do people extend at all?
Because lenders turn cautious below about eighty years and the premium rises sharply once marriage value applies. Waiting costs money rather than saving it. So the timing is a valuation decision long before it is a tax one.
Our guide to second homes covers other property.
Waiting makes a lease extension dearer.
Is there a statutory route?
There is, with its own qualifying conditions and a set formula for the premium. An informal deal with the freeholder is also possible on different terms. Both are capital spending for tax whichever route you take.
Our guide to the annual tax on enveloped dwellings covers held property.
Statutory or informal, the tax is the same.
What about ground rent?
Ongoing ground rent is a running cost rather than capital, so a landlord can set it against rental income. A statutory extension usually reduces it to nothing. So the extension removes a deduction as well as a liability.
Our guide to UK holiday lets covers letting costs.
Ground rent is a cost, the premium is not.
What about service charges?
Service charges are running costs too and follow the ground rent treatment. They have nothing to do with the extension premium. So keep the two kinds of payment clearly apart in your records.
Our guide to UK rental expenses covers household costs.
Running costs and capital stay separate.
Does a lease extension affect inheritance tax?
It converts cash into property value, which both estates measure at death. The flat is worth more and your bank balance is lower. So the estate total barely moves while its shape changes.
Our guide to long term residence and IHT covers estates.
The estate changes shape, not size.
What if a trust owns the flat?
Then the trust bears the cost and an American beneficiary may face reporting on the structure. Foreign trusts carry long annual forms. So check the American position before the trust spends anything.
Our guide to UK trust distributions covers trusts.
A trust adds forms to the transaction.
What if you are not American?
A British owner records the same capital cost and uses it on sale here. The American question only arises for citizens and green card holders. So the British treatment is identical either way.
Our guide to green card holders in the UK covers who is caught.
The British side does not care about passports.
How long should you keep the file?
Until the flat is sold and both returns for that year are agreed. That can easily be thirty years after completion. So ordinary record retention periods are nowhere near long enough.
Our guide to the statute of limitations covers time limits.
Thirty years is not an exaggeration.
Does a lease extension change the flat's value?
Usually by more than the premium itself, which is the whole commercial point of doing it. The gain only shows up when you sell. So the value rises quietly and the tax follows much later.
Our guide to UK REITs for US investors covers valuations.
Value rises now, tax arrives later.
Can you claim a loss on the flat?
If the eventual sale falls below the total cost including the extension, a loss arises in both systems. The rules on using it then differ sharply. So record the full cost to make the loss provable.
Our guide to wash sale rules covers losses.
A provable loss needs the full cost figure.
Who should get advice first?
Anybody buying a freehold through a company, anybody holding through a trust, and anybody about to sell. A plain statutory extension needs recording rather than advising. The structures are what cost money.
Our guide to an enrolled agent or a CPA covers advisers.
Structures need advice, simple extensions need filing.
How to handle a lease extension on both returns
- Treat the premium as capital, never as a rental expense.
- Add legal, valuation and stamp duty costs to the same figure.
- Record the exchange rate on the completion date.
- Scan the completion statement the week you complete.
- Store it with the deeds rather than that year's tax papers.
- Check any freehold company for American reporting.
- Expect nothing on either return until you sell.
- Produce all of it when the sale finally happens.
Mistakes and penalties we see with a lease extension
The first is claiming the premium against rental income, which is wrong in both countries.
The second is losing the completion statement, which quietly overstates the gain years later.
The third is forgetting the exchange rate, leaving the American basis impossible to compute properly.
The fourth is joining a freehold company without checking the American reporting that comes with it.
How US UK Tax Accountants helps
We record the cost properly in both currencies at the time, because that is when the information still exists.
Then we hold it until the sale year. Our property gains service covers the disposal.
If you are extending a lease on an American passport, get in touch before completion.
Last reviewed 14 November 2026. This article is general information and not personal tax advice.
Not sure where you stand?
Tell us what you hold across the US and UK. We come back with the scope and a fixed fee in writing, at no cost.
Get in TouchPrimary sources
Official guidance from the IRS, FinCEN and GOV.UK. Thresholds and rates on those pages are updated annually — check the current tax year before relying on a figure.



