Skip to content
All Insights

Roth Conversion While Living in the UK: Who Taxes It and When It Pays

Pensions · · 14 min read
Olive sapling beside a larger terracotta pot on a bench, a picture of a Roth conversion in the UK
Moving a plant into a bigger pot costs effort now for room to grow later, the bargain a Roth conversion strikes. In the UK, the question is whether both countries see the move the same way.

Figures relate to tax year 2026 (US)

For an American living in Britain, the IRS taxes a Roth conversion as ordinary income in the year you convert. The foreign earned income exclusion cannot touch it, because pension money is not earned income. On the British side, the treaty points towards no UK charge on a direct move between two IRAs. But HMRC has published nothing on a Roth conversion UK residents make.

So the real Roth conversion UK question is less about Britain and more about your American bracket. Convert when your US rate is low and keep the move inside the IRA system. The payoff arrives later as withdrawals that neither country taxes.

Key takeaways

  • A conversion is ordinary income on your US return for the year it happens.
  • The foreign earned income exclusion does not apply, because IRA money is unearned income.
  • Claiming the exclusion on your salary can push a conversion into a higher bracket.
  • HMRC has published no guidance on a Roth conversion UK residents make.
  • Article 18(1) of the treaty protects money transferred between pension schemes.
  • Conversion income is normally US-source, so old foreign tax credits cannot offset it directly.
  • Each conversion starts its own five-year clock for the 10% additional tax.
  • A qualified Roth withdrawal later is exempt in both countries under Article 17(1)(b).

What is a Roth conversion?

A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA. According to IRS Publication 590-A, the IRS treats it as a rollover whichever method you use. You pay income tax on the pre-tax money now. In exchange, qualified withdrawals later come out tax-free, including all the growth in between.

There are three ways to do it. Your custodian can redesignate the account, move it trustee-to-trustee, or pay it to you for a 60-day rollover. Since 2018 you cannot undo a conversion by recharacterising it, so the decision is final once the money moves.

How does the IRS tax a Roth conversion UK residents make?

Exactly as it would for someone living in Ohio. The converted amount goes on your Form 1040 as ordinary income for the year of the conversion, and Form 8606 reports it. Living in Britain changes nothing about the American charge, because the US taxes its citizens on worldwide income wherever they live.

Any nondeductible contributions you made in earlier years are not taxed again. Form 8606 tracks that basis, so keep every copy you have ever filed. If the forms are missing, the IRS treats the whole balance as pre-tax money.

The 10% additional tax on early distributions does not apply to the converted amount itself. However, anything you keep back rather than convert counts as an ordinary distribution.

Why can't the foreign earned income exclusion shelter it?

Because the exclusion only covers pay for work you do abroad. The IRS lists pensions and annuities as unearned income, and IRA money falls on that side of the line. So a conversion of $40,000 adds $40,000 of taxable income, however much British salary you also exclude in the same year.

Worse, the exclusion makes the conversion dearer. IRS Publication 54 says that once you claim the exclusion, your other income faces the rates that would apply without it. In practice, your excluded salary still pushes the conversion up into the higher brackets.

Does HMRC tax a Roth conversion UK residents make?

On the published material, probably not, but HMRC has never said so directly. Its Double Taxation Relief Manual page on the United States treaty covers IRA distributions and lump sums. However, it says nothing about moving money from a traditional IRA into a Roth. So the answer rests on the treaty text itself.

That text is helpful. Article 18(1) lets the UK tax income inside a US pension scheme only when it is paid to you. A transfer to another pension scheme does not count. Both traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs appear on the agreed list of US pension schemes in the 2001 exchange of notes.

Our reading is that a direct conversion is a transfer between two listed schemes, so nothing is paid to you for British purposes. Still, treat that as a well-founded position rather than a ruling.

What does the treaty actually say about Roth accounts?

Article 17(1)(a) lets the country you live in tax your pension. Article 17(1)(b) then carves out anything the scheme's home country would exempt. The US Treasury technical explanation uses a Roth IRA as its example. A distribution to a UK resident is exempt in Britain to the same extent it would be in America.

The same explanation adds that money rolled tax-free into another US IRA is exempt in Britain too. A conversion does not fit that sentence neatly, because America does tax it. That is why Article 18(1), not Article 17, does the work for a conversion.

Crucially, Article 1(5) lists both Article 17(1)(b) and Article 18(1) as exceptions to the saving clause. So these protections survive even for someone who is a citizen of one country and resident in the other.

Roth conversion UK treatment at a glance, 2026
EventUS taxUK position
Growth inside a traditional IRADeferredNot taxed until paid out, Article 18(1)
Direct trustee-to-trustee conversionOrdinary income in the yearNo published HMRC view; treaty points to no charge
60-day rollover conversionOrdinary income in the yearWeaker, because cash reaches you first
Qualified Roth withdrawalTax-freeExempt under Article 17(1)(b)
Non-qualified Roth withdrawalEarnings may be taxableExempt only to the US-exempt extent

Does the conversion method matter?

Yes, and more than most people expect. A trustee-to-trustee transfer or a redesignation never puts money in your hands. A 60-day rollover does, even briefly. Because Article 18(1) depends on the money being transferred rather than paid out, the direct routes give you the cleaner British position.

So ask your custodian for a direct conversion in writing. Keep the confirmation that shows the money went from one IRA to the other without passing through your bank account.

The same logic applies to tax withholding. Any sum the custodian keeps back for the IRS has been paid out rather than transferred. It may also attract the 10% additional tax if you are under 59 and a half.

Can foreign tax credits absorb the conversion tax?

Not directly, and this catches people out because a foreign tax credit needs foreign tax on the same income. If Britain does not tax the conversion, there is no new UK tax to credit. And according to IRS Publication 514, pension income is sourced where the work was done and where the trust sits. For a US IRA, that usually means America.

Carryovers from earlier years do not change that. They can only be used against US tax on foreign-source income within the same basket. Conversion income is normally US-source, so it sits outside the limitation altogether.

Treaty re-sourcing does not rescue the position either. It only turns US-source income into foreign-source income where the UK actually taxes it. For the background on the ten-year carryforward, see our guide to foreign tax credit carryover rules.

How can a conversion still use spare UK tax?

Indirectly, through the credit limitation. The credit on your UK salary is capped at the share of your US tax that relates to foreign income. When a conversion pushes your total tax up, that share grows in dollars. So spare UK tax from the current year, or carried over, can cover part of the extra bill.

The effect is that the conversion ends up taxed nearer your average US rate than your top rate. It only works if you claim credits on your salary rather than the exclusion.

A worked example with 2026 brackets

Take an illustrative single filer in Bristol. Her UK salary gives $100,000 of US taxable income after deductions, and her UK tax on it is higher than the US tax. She converts $50,000 in 2026. The figures use the 2026 single schedule in IRS Publication 505.

  1. US tax on $100,000 alone is $5,800 plus 22% of $49,600, which is $16,712. UK credits wipe it out.
  2. US tax on $150,000 is $17,966 plus 24% of $44,300, which is $28,598.
  3. The credit limit is $28,598 times 100,000 over 150,000, which is about $19,065.
  4. Her spare UK tax covers that limit, leaving about $9,533 to pay, roughly 19% of the conversion.
  5. Had she excluded the salary instead, the conversion would cost $28,598 minus $16,712, which is $11,886.

So in this example the credit route saves about $2,350 on the same Roth conversion UK move. A retiree with no other taxable income would pay far less on a Roth conversion UK move of the same size. Tax on $50,000 alone is $1,240 plus 12% of $37,600, which is $5,752.

When does a Roth conversion make sense from the UK?

Usually when your US rate today is lower than it will be when you draw the money. Typical moments are a gap year between jobs, early retirement before state pensions start, or a year with large spare UK tax credits. If you expect to retire in Britain, the treaty exemption for qualified Roth withdrawals adds to the case.

  • You are in the 10% or 12% US bracket for 2026, up to $50,400 of single taxable income.
  • You can pay the US tax from savings rather than from the IRA.
  • You will not need the money for at least five years.
  • You expect to stay in the UK or move back to America in retirement.

When is converting a poor idea?

When the tax today is higher than the tax you are likely to face later. That often means you are already in the 32% bracket or above, which starts at $201,775 of single taxable income for 2026. It also includes anyone who would have to raid the IRA itself to pay the bill.

Another warning sign is a planned move to a third country. Plenty of countries do not recognise a Roth at all and may tax withdrawals as ordinary pension income. In that case you pay American tax now and foreign tax later, which is the worst of both.

How do the five-year rules work?

There are two separate clocks. The first decides whether withdrawals of earnings are qualified, and it starts with the first tax year you ever funded a Roth IRA. The second applies to each conversion separately. Withdraw converted money within five years and under age 59 and a half, and the 10% additional tax can come back.

For example, IRS Publication 590-B explains that a conversion made at any point in 2026 starts its clock on 1 January 2026. So a December conversion gains almost a full year on paper.

Each later conversion starts a fresh clock. Keep a simple table of dates and amounts, because custodians do not track this for you.

Should you convert before you arrive in the UK?

Often, yes, if the timing is in your control. A conversion completed while you are still resident only in America raises no British question at all. The US tax is the same either way. Moving the decision earlier simply removes the one open point in any Roth conversion UK analysis.

The edge case is the year of arrival. If split-year treatment applies, the UK part of the year begins on your arrival date. A conversion made before that date falls in the overseas part. Our guide to split-year treatment for Americans covers the conditions.

What about converting after you leave Britain?

Leaving changes the British side but not the American one. Once you are no longer UK resident, HMRC has no claim on the conversion at all. Then the only Roth conversion UK question left is your US bracket that year. It is often low in a year of moving and changing jobs.

If you are moving back to America, also think about state tax. A conversion in the year you arrive in a high-tax state may cost more than one completed before you leave London.

Does a 401(k) conversion work the same way?

Broadly, yes. A 401(k) is a 401(a) plan, which the exchange of notes lists as a US pension scheme, so the Article 18(1) analysis carries over. You can convert inside the plan to a designated Roth account, or roll the balance directly into a Roth IRA. Either way, America taxes the pre-tax part as ordinary income.

An in-plan conversion keeps the money inside one scheme, which is the tidiest British position of all. Check whether your old employer's plan offers it, because many do not. For the wider picture on keeping American plans while living here, read our guide to US retirement accounts in the UK.

Can you convert a required minimum distribution?

No. IRS Publication 590-A says you cannot convert amounts that must come out of a traditional IRA for that year, including the year you reach age 73. Take the required amount first as a normal taxable distribution, then convert some or all of what remains.

That required withdrawal is a pension payment, so it is taxable in Britain under Article 17(1)(a). Then claim a foreign tax credit in the usual way for the UK tax on it.

Does a former US state still want its share?

It might, if you never properly broke your domicile there. Some states keep taxing former residents who left without clear evidence of a permanent move. A large conversion is exactly the kind of income that draws attention from a state tax office.

Check your position before you convert, not after. Our guide to US state tax for expats explains how domicile is usually tested.

Should you keep contributing to a Roth while UK resident?

The 2026 limit is $7,500, or $8,600 at 50 and over, according to IRS Publication 590-A. But earnings you exclude under the foreign earned income exclusion do not count as compensation. So many expats who claim it have no room to contribute at all. An excess contribution then draws a 6% charge every year it stays put.

The British side is less clear. The treaty does not expressly strip protection from money paid in after you arrive, and HMRC has not published a view. Therefore we treat new contributions made while UK resident as an open point and keep them separate in the records.

Should you have tax withheld from the conversion?

Usually not, because any amount withheld is not converted and counts as a taxable distribution. It may also attract the 10% additional tax if you are under 59 and a half. It also gives up the cleaner treaty position of a pure transfer. Paying the US bill from other savings keeps the whole sum growing tax-free.

Plan the cash flow instead. A large conversion early in the year may call for an estimated tax payment so that you avoid an underpayment charge.

What records should you keep?

Keep the custodian's conversion confirmation, the Form 1099-R and Form 5498 for the year, and every Form 8606 you have filed. Add a note of the conversion date for the five-year clock. If you file a UK return, keep a short working note of why no British tax arises.

In our practice we also add a brief white-space note to the Self Assessment return. Disclosing the position openly is better than leaving HMRC to find the US forms years later.

Mistakes we see with a Roth conversion UK residents make

  • Assuming the foreign earned income exclusion will cover the conversion.
  • Using a 60-day rollover when a direct transfer was available.
  • Withholding tax from the conversion and triggering the 10% additional tax.
  • Counting on old foreign tax credit carryovers to absorb US-source income.
  • Converting in a year when the exclusion on salary pushes the bracket up.
  • Losing track of the separate five-year clock for each conversion.
  • Converting just before a move to a country that does not recognise a Roth.

How to plan a Roth conversion from the UK

  1. Work out your 2026 US taxable income and bracket before converting anything.
  2. Decide whether to claim credits or the exclusion on your salary that year.
  3. Take any required minimum distribution first.
  4. Ask the custodian for a direct trustee-to-trustee conversion in writing.
  5. Pay the US tax from savings, not from withholding.
  6. Record the conversion date, amount and any basis on Form 8606.
  7. Note the treaty position on your UK return if you file one.

How US UK Tax Accountants helps

We model the conversion on both returns before any money moves, including the credit limitation and your likely bracket in later years. Our treaty relief service covers the Article 17 and 18 positions and how to present them to HMRC.

If you are weighing a Roth conversion UK plan this year, contact our team well before 31 December. The timing is then still yours to choose.

Last reviewed 19 November 2026. This article is general information and not personal tax advice. Figures are for the 2026 US tax year. HMRC has not published a position on conversions, so take advice on your own facts.

Not sure where you stand?

Tell us what you hold across the US and UK. We come back with the scope and a fixed fee in writing, at no cost.

Get in Touch
Related services

Questions, Answered.

Common questions on this topic

Is a Roth conversion taxable in the UK?
HMRC has not published guidance on conversions. The treaty points towards no UK charge on a direct transfer, because Article 18(1) only lets Britain tax pension scheme income when it is paid to you rather than moved to another scheme. Both traditional and Roth IRAs are listed US pension schemes, so a trustee-to-trustee conversion has the strongest position.
Can I use the foreign earned income exclusion on a conversion?
No. The exclusion only covers pay for work done abroad, and the IRS treats pension and IRA money as unearned income. Claiming the exclusion on your salary can actually raise the cost, because the conversion is then taxed at the rates that would apply if the excluded salary were still counted.
Will my foreign tax credit carryovers cover the US tax?
Not directly. Conversion income from a US IRA is normally US-source, and carryovers can only reduce US tax on foreign-source income. However, a conversion raises your total US tax, which lifts the credit limit on your UK salary. Spare UK tax can then cover part of the extra bill indirectly.
How much US tax would a $50,000 conversion cost in 2026?
It depends on your other income. For a single filer with no other taxable income, the 2026 schedule gives $5,752. For a single filer whose UK salary already gives $100,000 of taxable income, the extra tax is about $9,533 if credits cover the salary, or $11,886 if the salary is excluded instead.
When does the five-year clock start on a conversion?
On 1 January of the year you convert, whatever month the money actually moves. Each conversion has its own clock for the 10% additional tax if you are under 59 and a half. A separate clock, starting with your first ever Roth contribution year, decides whether earnings come out as qualified withdrawals.
Can I undo a Roth conversion if the tax is higher than expected?
No. Recharacterisation of conversions ended with conversions made in 2018 and later, so the decision is final once the money moves. That is why it pays to model the bracket, the credit limitation and any state tax exposure before asking the custodian to make the transfer.